UNITED STATES. Unite Greenland Canada USA and Panama? Trump didn’t invent anything

780
Screenshot

Donald Trump has made some geopolitical statements that have sent shivers down the spines of many: taking Greenland, Canada and the Panama Canal. They seem like political follies but if you look closely they are not new: in the US there was a movement that wanted to unite North America into a single nation, it was the “Technocratic Movement”. It was a “nonconformist” group from the 1930s that wanted to reorganize US society, eliminating waste and making North America, in its entirety highly productive, the pinnacle of technology and science. The Technocrats, also Technocracy Inc, proposed uniting Canada, Greenland, Mexico, the United States and parts of Central America into a single continental unit, governed by technocratic principles, rather than by national borders and traditional political divisions, reports The Conversation. It sounds a lot like the Trump Administration 2.0 agenda on merging the United States with Canada.

Meanwhile, the DOGE led by Elon Musk, has also outlined a vision of efficiency cuts by cutting red tape, cutting jobs, and getting rid of organizational leaders and public employees deemed “antagonistic”; an approach similar to some of the ideas of the Technocrats.

As The Conversation reports: “What did the Technocrats want to get rid of? The 1930s movement was an educational and research organization that advocated radical reorganization of political, social, and economic structures in the United States and Canada. It was based on a book called Technocracy, published in 1921 by an engineer named Walter Henry Smyth, which captured new ideas about management and science. The movement gained significant attention during the Great Depression, a period of mass unemployment and economic problems that lasted from 1929 to 1939. It was a time when widespread economic failures spurred radical ideas for systemic change. Technocracy appealed to those who saw technological advances as a potential solution to economic inefficiency and inequality. The Technocrats gained traction largely because of the work of Howard Scott, an engineer and economist, along with a group of engineers and academics at Columbia University. In 1932, Scott founded the Technical Alliance, which later evolved into Technocracy Inc.”

The movement attracted a significant following among engineers, scientists, and progressive thinkers. The ideological foundation of the movement was based on the belief that industrial production and distribution should be managed scientifically; capitalism and socialism were inefficient and prone to corruption, but a scientifically planned economy could ensure abundance, stability, and equity. A very Soviet program, mutatis mutandis.

In the 1930s, members of Technocracy Inc sought to replace market-based economies and political governance with a system in which experts made decisions based on data, efficiency, and technological feasibility; they believed that mechanization and automation could eliminate much of the need for human labor, reducing working hours while maintaining productivity. Goods and services would be distributed based on scientific calculations of need and sustainability.

The movement quickly lost momentum in the mid- to late 1930s: critics feared that a government run by unelected experts would lead to an authoritarian form of government, in which decisions would be made without the input or democratic oversight. Musk has a family connection to the movement, so he’s likely aware of it: his maternal grandfather, Joshua N. Haldeman, was a leading figure in the technocracy movement in Canada during the 1930s and ’40s.

His initiatives are in line with Technocrats: they prioritize innovation and automation, to optimize human civilization through scientific and technological means.

However, Musk’s approach to commerce remains firmly rooted in the free market, not a five-year plan. But Trump believes that politicians like him should run the country, along with partners like Musk. The government of the Optimates, in short.

The rise of artificial intelligence and big data has reignited discussions about the role (and scope) of technocracy in modern society: in countries like Singapore and China, governance is dominated by departments led by people with tech backgrounds, who gain elite status.

The technocratic movement evaporated, but its central ideas continue to shape contemporary debates about the intersection of technology and government planning—and who is best in charge.

Luigi Medici

Follow our updates on Geopolitical Gleanings - Spigolature geopolitiche: https://t.me/agc_NW and on our blog The Gleanings of AGCNEWS - Le Spigolature di AGCNEWS: https://spigolatureagcnews.blogspot.com/